Comparative analysis of neonatal sequelae after classic M. Stark and modified cesarean section


  • I.Z. Gladchuk Odessa National Medical University
  • A.G. Volyanskaya Odessa National Medical University
  • Y.V. Herman Odessa National Medical University
  • D.O. Grigurko Odessa National Medical University
Keywords: caesarean section, neonatal period, complications, perinatal consequences

Abstract

Over the last twenty years, a sharp perinatal birth rate has registered high perinatal morbidity and mortality in the country. Despite the fact that the number of cesarean sections is constantly increasing, the perinatal mortality rate in the country remains positive and in 2017 was 7.9%%. The purpose of the study was a comparative analysis of the features of the course of the early neonatal period and the frequency of neonatal complications in classical cesarean section according to M. Stark and according to a modified method for improving perinatal outcomes. The selection of patients for the comparative study was performed by type of surgery (classic M. Stark technique or modified technique), which was conducted at the clinical basis of the Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology №1 ONMedU for the period from 2015 to 2018 according to a randomized principle in the obstetric department of the Kherson Regional Clinical Hospital (clinical base of the Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology No. 1 ONMedU). The formation of clinical groups was carried out according to retrospective data from 205 birth histories, the delivery of which was carried out by caesarean section. Statistical processing of the results was carried out using application R of the Microsoft Exel 2003 program. Analysis of quantitative indicators was analyzed using the arithmetic mean value (M) and the error in determining the average value (± m). Qualitative indicators were measured in absolute and relative (percentage) values. The significance of differences in the parametric characteristics in the appropriate groups was evaluated using Student's t test (t - test) and analysis of variance (ANOVA). In the calculations, the differences were considered statistically significant at p <0.05 (95% confidence level (CI) and at p <0.01 (99% confidence level). By using modified access to the abdominal cavity, which involved grasping the peritoneum with the index finger and stretching all layers of the anterior wall in a blunt fashion by two surgeons at the same time, it was almost twice possible to reduce the time to fetal extraction in the main study group (p˂0.001). The condition of newborns on the Apgar scale at 1 and 5 minutes of life in the first clinical group of the study was better (p=0.005). Due to the modified features of fetal extraction, it was possible to reduce the incidence of HID CNS in newborns (p=0.022), to 6 times reduce the need for treatment at the III level (p=0.004). The indicator of early neonatal mortality in the newborns of the first clinical group was zero, whereas in the comparison group 2 cases were recorded. However, the difference is not significant (p=0.223). Thus, the modified Caesarean section improves the overall condition of the newborns according to the Apgar scale at 1 and 5 minutes of life, is accompanied by a decrease in the frequency of some complications in the early neonatal period, creates a certain additional reserve for the improvement of perinatal complications and requires further comprehensive studies.

References

1. Herman, Yu. V, & Hryhurko, D. O. (2018). Osnovni Nota Bene modyfikovanoi metodyky kesarevoho roztynu za M. Stark [The main Nota Bene modified cesarean section technique by M. Stark]. Zdorovia zhinky – Woman's health, 7 (133), 22–25.

2. Herman, Yu., Herman, O., Hryhurko, D., Holovko, N., & Palahniuk, Ya. (2017). Modyfikovanyi kesariv roztyn za M. Starkom u vykonanni dvokh khirurhiv [Modified caesarean section by M. Stark performed by two surgeons]. Zhinochyi likar – Female Doctor, 2, 55–59. Vziato z https://z-l.com.ua/ru/article/792&summary.

3. Korchynska, O. O., & Hulpe, K. Yu. (2013). Materynski ta perynatalni naslidky, poviazani z kesarevym roztynom: porivnialnyi analiz iz dosvidom koleh zi Slovachchyny [Maternal and perinatal outcomes of caesarean section: a comparative analysis with the experience of colleagues from Slovakia]. Problemy klinichnoi pediatrii – Problems in Clinical Pediatrics, 3, 35–39. Vziato z http://nbuv.gov.ua/UJRN/pkp_2013_3_9.

4. Krasnopolskij, V. I. (Red.). (2018). Kesarevo sechenie. Problemy abdominalnogo akusherstva: rukovodstvo dlya vrachej (3-e izd., pererab. i dop.). [Cesarean section. Problems of abdominal obstetrics: a guide for physicians (3rd ed., rev. and suppl.)]. Moskva: SIMK.

5. Nakaz MOZ Ukrainy pro zatverdzhennia klinichnykh protokoliv z akusherskoi ta hinekolohichnoi dopomohy № 977 vid 27.12.2011 // 2011. [Order of the Ministry of Health of Ukraine on approval of clinical protocols on obstetric and gynecological care № 977 of 27.12.2011 // 2011].

6. Nakaz MOZ Ukrainy pro zatverdzhennia klinichnykh protokoliv z akusherskoi ta hinekolohichnoi dopomohy № 976 vid 27.12.2011 // 2011. [Order of the Ministry of Health of Ukraine on approval of clinical protocols on obstetric and gynecological care № 976 of 27.12.2011 // 2011].

7. Nunha, K. Zh. (2017). Perynatalni naslidky povtornoho kesareva roztynu u zhinok, yaki bahato narodzhuvaly [Perinatal effects of re-caesarean section in women who have given birth a lot]. Zbirnyk naukovykh prats spivrobitnykiv NMAPO imeni P.L. Shupyka – Collection of scientific works of employees NMA Shupyk Postgraduate Education, 28 (2), 29–33. Kyiv.

8. Pochynok, T. V., & Klymchuk, V. V. (2014). Kesarskyi roztyn yak faktor ryzyku rozvytku somatychnoi patolohii u ditei. [Caesarean section as a risk factor for somatic pathology in children]. Neonatolohiia, khirurhiia ta perynatalna medytsyna – Neonatology, Surgery, and Perinatal Medicine, 4 (2), 117–123. Vziato s http://nbuv.gov.ua/UJRN/.

9. Usevych, I. A., & Kolesnyk, V. L. (2017). Vplyv katehorii urhentnosti kesareva roztynu na adaptatsiini mozhlyvosti vahitnykh ta rodil [Influence of cesarean section on the adaptive capacity of pregnant women and mothers]. Zdorovia zhinky – Women's Health, 5 (121), 10–15. Vziato z http://nbuv.gov.ua/UJRN/.

10. Filimonova, N. B., Fil, I. O., & Mykhailova, T. S. (2004). Statystychnyi analiz danykh vidpovidno do zasad naukovo obhruntovanoi medytsyny [Statistical analysis of data in accordance with the principles of science of sound medicine]. Medytsyna zaliznychnoho transportu Ukrainy – Railway medicine of Ukraine, 4, 85–93.
Published
2019-09-02
How to Cite
Gladchuk, I., Volyanskaya, A., Herman, Y., & Grigurko, D. (2019). Comparative analysis of neonatal sequelae after classic M. Stark and modified cesarean section. Reports of Vinnytsia National Medical University, 23(3), 414-419. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.31393/reports-vnmedical-2019-23(3)-13